Employing PDIA to Improve Agriculture Admin Data Systems in Malawi

May 3, 2018 Data Management Systems and MEL
Vinisha Bhatia-Murdach, Emily Fung
News/Events, Process, Program, Results Data

The amount of agriculture data being reported, collected, and visualized is growing exponentially. Organizations like Global Open Data for Agriculture and Nutrition (GODAN) and Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) are promoting sharing, accessibility, and use of agriculture and nutrition data worldwide – because progress-limiting practices impact the entire agricultural value chain, inhibiting smallholder farmers, agricultural productivity, and food security.

This need for more and better agriculture data is not lost on governments. In fact, several are making it a priority to create or hone national systems to support domestic agriculture and farming. The Africa Agriculture Status Report emphasizes that efforts to “modernize the agriculture sector… could make a valuable contribution to national economic growth in many countries, and to poverty reduction.” The Senegal Emerging Plan (ESP) prioritizes agriculture as a key driver to sustainable economic growth, and last year Senegal announced new initiatives with the Global Partnership for Sustainable Development Data (GPSDD) to map farms, as well as collect and use agricultural statistics to fill data gaps about its farming industry.

But as we’ve asked before – are the data we’re spending so much to collect truly relevant for decision makers? In this case, are they useful and used by government, beyond just reporting processes? Large scale Management Information Systems (MIS) – whether for governments, development agencies, or NGOs – are rarely created based on a holistic, deep understanding of intended users and decision makers. Until now!

We’re proud to announce that, through our Results Data Initiative (RDI), we’re working with Malawi’s Ministry of Agriculture, Irrigation and Water Development (MOAIWD) to design a National Agriculture Management Information System (NAMIS). This initiative aims to improve the administrative and results data systems used in the country’s agriculture sector, by putting users at the center of system design.

This work is innovative and inventive, for two reasons. Firstly, we’re exploring the intersection between expectation of agriculture data needs and the realities of agriculture data users – working to ensure data is relevant, useful, and used.

Secondly, we’re taking a problem-driven, iterative, and adaptive (PDIA) approach to inform building of a national government information system. In designing the NAMIS, we are guided by a belief that a holistic, needs-based national data system requires two elements: (1) putting future users at the center of system design, and (2) never assuming we know what these users might need.

How are we doing this? We’ve adapted our PDIA approach from RDI’s cross-ministerial workshops in the health sector in Tanzania, combining it with the MOAIWD’s goal of designing a system to meet the diverse needs of government and non-governmental stakeholders. We’re also building upon other innovative work taking place in Malawi: integrating lessons learned from the Malawi health sector DHIS2 implementation, and from DG, the AidData Center for Development Policy, and the Strauss Center’s Climate Change and African Political Stability (CCAPS) program’s work to geocode the country’s Aid Management Platform (AMP) data. So far, we have spoken with over 100 people in the Malawi agriculture sector, and are working with MOAIWD and the GoM to develop takeaways, next steps, and what the MIS should look like to really meet user needs for decision making – not just reporting.

Stay tuned for additional takeaways and lessons learned in building a user-centric MIS, including a post in which we’ll explore the many ways our preconceptions about user needs have been proven wrong!

Share This Post

Related from our library

Letting the Sunshine in: Building Inclusive, Accountable, and Equitable Climate Finance Ecosystems

In April, DG, HackCorruption, and the Thai Youth Anti-Corruption Network hosted a roundtable in Bangkok to discuss climate financing. This blog explores the main takeaway: a multi-disciplinary and multi-stakeholder approach that prioritizes local contexts, inclusive governance, transparency, accountability, and equitable distribution of resources is essential to impactful climate financing.

May 13, 2024 Strategic Advisory Services
A participant at a hackathon event.
DG Developing Open Source AI Tool to Help with the Fight against Corruption

We’re excited to announce our forthcoming open-source AI tool to support anti-corruption work. The tool, which we hope to register as a Digital Public Good, will be used to extract text from complicated contracts and support anti-corruption efforts by increasing accessibility of and transparency around hard-to-access information.

April 23, 2024  
Three “Hacks” in Advancing Anti-Corruption Work To Strengthen Accountability

Since partnering with Accountability Lab (AL) on HackCorruption in 2023, staff from Development Gateway: An IREX Venture (DG) and AL have mentored teams from the hackathons hosted by the project, which is aimed at leveraging innovative digital tools to identify and fight corruption. After serving as the mentorship team for hackathon winners, DGers Gabriel Inchauspe and Kelley Sams, along with AL’s David Sada have identified three hacks in mentoring anti-corruption change-makers and ultimately, furthering transparency and accountability through the creation and use of digital tools.

April 3, 2024