Why Open Doesn’t Mean All: Hedging Against the Technology Matthew Effect

May 10, 2016
Innovation

What makes technology attractive for a user? Why would one change their behavior to adapt to something they aren’t used to using? I’ve been doing a lot of thinking around what makes technology (or really any product) useable and “inclusive.” As an organization that aims to help those in the development space get and use the information they need to improve lives, we’re constantly thinking about the best ways to bring people into a culture of product use.

We’re in step with other organizations and companies working to make technology more inclusive. Sean McDonald of FrontlineSMS’s recent piece on the Open (Data) Market pushes this concept further. He explores the actual beneficiaries of open licensing, citing the misplaced belief that open means access for all. He also references the Technology Matthew Effect, which says that with all things equal, the rich get richer, the poor get poorer. You could remove “open” from his argument to talk about “data” and “technology” to arrive at a similar conclusion: Without purposeful inclusion of those who are not targeted in the typical market, the tech4dev community may increase the gap between the tech-rich and the tech-poor.

My colleague Paige Kirby recently traveled to Timor-Leste as part of a team that is working to understand how data and technology are used to make decisions about development assistance. She came back with an anecdote that got my wheels turning. When discussing challenges to data use, a development partner shared a common pitfall with technology: when a tool is designed for all users, it benefits none. By trying to make something appeal simultaneously to “techie” and “non-techie” users, we run the risk of meeting each user’s needs halfway. Without designing for a particular audience, our technology won’t have much uptake.

“If you build it, [they all] will come” may have worked for Mr. Costner, but it should not be the driving force behind tech4dev solutions. We need to actively work to define the “they” as those who may be forgotten, or those who may typically have difficulty accessing data, particularly dashboards, maps, etc. By doing this, we can actively hedge against the Matthew Effect in data tools and tech4dev to allow for demand (and use!) to meet the supply (of technology, data, and tools) by designing for low and lowest-capacity users.

Image Credit: Enviu CC BY-NC 2.0

Share This Post

Related from our library

To Enable W-SMEs to Thrive in Côte d’Ivoire We Start by Listening to their Data and Digital Needs

This blog is co-written by Development Gateway’s Aminata Camara, Senior Consultant; Kathryn Alexander, Senior Program Advisor; and MCC‘s Agnieszka Rawa, Managing Director of Data Collaboratives for Local Impact (DCLI). On June 28th, 2021, MCC, USAID, Microsoft, Thinkroom, and Development Gateway will be co-hosting a workshop to share, validate, inform, and build on recent research on

June 24, 2021  
Artificial Intelligence: A Silver Bullet or Scrap Metal for Global Development?

When someone mentions artificial intelligence (AI), it’s easy to conjure up two conflicting images: the first, killer robots whizzing past, replacing human jobs, daily tasks, and social interactions in a post-apocalyptic world; the second, a C-3PO-esque personality revolutionizing our health and food systems. Pondering this, we are also inclined to explore the question, where does

February 6, 2019 Global Data Policy
DG and ONG 3D: Collaborating to Engage Senegalese Stakeholders in Open Contracting

As we've covered before, DG is pleased to be supporting the advancement of Open Contracting (OC) and enhancing data use in Senegal and Uganda. Through the Hewlett Foundation, we'll be completing a series of data use projects over the next two years, collaborating with local actors and developing tools to take existing open contracting efforts to the next level. In Senegal, we're working with the Autorité de Régulation des Marchés Publics (ARMP) and civil society partners to support the Government of Senegal and other key stakeholders in using procurement data to enhance procurement results.

September 11, 2018 Open Contracting and Procurement Analytics